Well look who came crawling back to their blog acting like they haven’t been AWOL for 2 months. Me, that’s who.
When I was a little boy I was always taught that if you haven’t got something constructive to blog about then you shouldn’t blog at all, which was weird because when I was young blogs didn’t exist. Maybe I was just mis-hearing the word ‘blob’? Still doesn’t make sense.
Anywho I’ve been away so long because I didn’t have much to say on the world of Sitcoms, my writing had dried to a creative trickle and life, as it often does, got in the way. But just like your wayward Daddy, i’m back (for now) with a six-pack of beer and some low-paying construction work, so come and sit on my knee and let’s pretend I was never away.
The subject of this blog is ‘knowing when to end your sitcom before you shit the bed’ or as I like to call it ‘not pulling a Scrubs’.
If you’re a fan of television comedy it’s more than likely that at some point you have bemoaned the cancelling of an amazing show well before its time. You have pulled your hair out at the fact that Arrested Development was cancelled whilst ‘My Family’ was allowed to birth forth turgid episode after turgid episode from it’s rotten comedic yawning. When a great show gets cancelled it’s easy to blame the masses, the people in the middle, the people who like Peter Kay, the ones who mindlessly consume regardless of quality and who watch easy, terrible television instead of well written, intelligent shows. We point the finger and say ‘You, plebeians are the problem. If only you’d be more discerning! You’ve ruined it for us all’, then we get on our high horses, ride to our ivory towers and put on the latest series of 30 Rock even though it hasn’t been good since series 3.
Y’see, to me a show that goes on too long is infinitely worse than a show that doesn’t go on long enough. Party Down was cancelled after 2 series. It was a terrible, crying shame- but at the end of the day those 20 episodes of pure comedy gold exist untainted for me to enjoy forever. Like Kurt Cobain, James Dean and the McRibwich it never got the chance to sell-out, turn shit and disappoint me in a way that so many other shows have.
On the other end of the spectrum is 30 Rock. When 30 Rock started, you wouldn’t find a stronger cheerleader for the show than me. I loved the writing, the cast and the storylines and ate through the series like this guy ate through cats. When it was time for series four to begin I went in just like I had before- optimistic and eager to enjoy. But although it was far from terrible, something had changed- the characters seemed bigger, more cartoonish, the plots seemed like a thin framework on which to hang surrealist jokes that meant nothing and the tone seemed more laboured and desperate for a laugh. I watched the whole of season 4, hoping it would pick up but it didn’t really. After it had finished I wrote it off as a minor blip on 30 Rock’s run and looked forward to the fifth series starting in the near future.
I wish I could give you my feelings on the fifth series but in all honesty I never finished it. 5 episodes in and I was done. I have no vitriolic feelings towards the show- I feel nothing for it. It exists, I used to like it, but for me the show has gone on too long and the makers no longer know what story they are telling. Jenna is crazy, Tracy is crazier, Kenneth is creepy and sincere, Jack is the definitive republican and Liz likes food and embarrassing herself. I get it. But after the millionth joke about the same thing i’m no longer laughing.
It might feel like i’m being overly harsh to show, and I certainly don’t mean to imply it is the worst offender of what I am talking about it, but it’s certainly the most recent example for me. There are countless other shows that have encountered the same pitfalls as 30 Rock and went on for another 5 or 6 series.
Friends, Scrubs, The Simpsons and Roseanne are shows that not only went on too long- how bad they ended up being actually ruined my enjoyment of the earlier episodes. I can’t watch Scrubs at all anymore, not even the 4 boxsets I have on DVD because I know where the characters end up and how it went out with a whimper rather than a bang.
Look at the shows that have an finite shelf-life (either set by their creators or cancelled by the broadcasters). The UK Office, Arrested Development and Party Down never had a bad episode, Eastbound & Down will finish after its 3rd series and is incredible whilst Look Around You, Nathan Barley and Garth Merenghi’s Darkplace are untouchable. Like any good story it’s good to know where you are going when you start. If you don’t have an ending it’s easy to get lost and become something different than what you set out to be. There’s nothing wrong with doing what you set out to do and getting out before you outstay your welcome, if anything it’s honourable. Sticking it out longer whilst trying to reach the same heights as yesteryear will only end in tears.
We spend so much time bemoaning when great shows finish that we forget that sometimes this is the best thing for them. Better to go out in an explosion of goodwill then limp towards your death long after you should have been put down. So next time someone tells you how all the good shows die young just put your hand on their shoulder, look them in the eye and tell them sometimes it’s good to kill your baby.
LB

